Complex numbers – made up of real and imaginary parts – often yield surprising results when raised to imaginary powers. In this article, we explore four fascinating cases:
- (-1)^i
- The i-th root of -1
- i^i
- The i-th root of i
Remarkably, all four produce real numbers – not just one, but infinitely many – thanks to the periodic properties of complex exponentiation. Let’s uncover these results using Euler’s formula and polar form.
What Are Complex Numbers
A complex number is written as:
z = a + bi
Where:
- a is the real part
- b is the imaginary part
- i is the imaginary unit, where i² = -1
Complex numbers are crucial in solving equations like x² + 1 = 0 and appear widely in physics, engineering, and advanced mathematics.
To understand complex powers, we must use Euler’s formula and represent complex numbers in polar form.
Euler’s Formula and Polar Form
Euler’s formula bridges complex exponentials and trigonometry:
e^(iθ) = cos(θ) + i sin(θ)
Any complex number can be written in polar form:
z = r e^(iθ)
Where:
- r is the magnitude (|z|)
- θ is the argument (angle with the positive real axis)
This form simplifies complex exponentiation and makes it easier to extract real results from imaginary powers.
Case 1: (-1)^i – Raising -1 to an Imaginary Power
Express -1 in polar form:
-1 = e^(iπ) (since cos(π) + i sin(π) = -1)
Now calculate:
(-1)^i = (e^(iπ))^i = e^(i²π) = e^(-π) ≈ 0.04321
This is a real number.
Due to periodicity (θ = π + 2kπ), the general form becomes:
(-1)^i = e^[-(π + 2kπ)], k ∈ ℤ
Each value of k gives a unique real number. Principal value is e^(–π).
Case 2: The i-th Root of -1
We interpret the i-th root of –1 as:
(-1)^(1/i) = (-1)^(-i)
Using polar form:
(-1)^(-i) = (e^(iπ))^(-i) = e^(-i²π) = e^π ≈ 23.1407
With periodicity (π + 2kπ), we have:
(-1)^(1/i) = e^(π+2kπ), k ∈ ℤ
Another infinite set of real numbers. Principal value is e^π.
Case 3: i^i – Imaginary Base and Exponent
The polar form of i is:
i = e^(iπ/2) (since cos(π/2) + i sin(π/2) = i)
Now compute:
i^i = (e^(iπ/2))^i = e^(i²π/2) = e^(-π/2) ≈ 0.20788
Taking periodicity into account:
i^i = e^[-(π/2+2kπ)], k ∈ ℤ
All values are real. Principal value is e^(–π/2).
Case 4: The i-th Root of i
We rewrite the i-th root of i as:
i^(1/i) = i^(-i)
Using the polar form:
i^(-i) = (e^(iπ/2))^(-i) = e^(-i²π/2) = e^(π/2) ≈ 4.8105
Considering periodicity:
i^(1/i) = e^(π/2+2kπ), k ∈ ℤ
Again, an infinite set of real numbers. Principal value is e^(π/2).
Conclusion: Infinite Real Numbers from Imaginary Powers
Each of the four complex powers surprisingly yields real results:
- (-1)^i = e^(-π-2kπ)
- (-1)^(1/i) = e^(π+2kπ)
- i^i = e^(-π/2-2kπ)
- i^(1/i) = e^(π/2+2kπ)
These infinite families of real numbers highlight the beauty and power of Euler’s formula and complex exponentiation. What may seem like abstract or paradoxical operations actually yield precise, elegant, and real results.
It is important to note not only that all values are real numbers, but also that the values of the i-th root are greater than the values of the i-th power of the corresponding number.
This was a really fascinating read. I’ve always been intrigued by how something as abstract as imaginary numbers can produce real, usable results. The way you broke down (-1)^i and i^i made it super easy to follow. It’s wild how concepts like this actually show up in the real world, especially in engineering and physics. Great job explaining it!
Thanks Shawn
Great article! The way you demystify how these expressions yield real numbers is truly enlightening. It’s fascinating to see Euler’s formula and polar coordinates bring clarity to such counterintuitive results. I’m curious, how do these concepts extend to more general forms like (a+bi)c+di(a + bi)^{c + di}(a+bi)c+di? Also, how do we determine the principal value among the infinite possibilities? Thanks for the insightful read! Debra
Thank you, Debra! I’m glad you found the breakdown helpful. Complex powers can definitely feel counterintuitive at first. Your questions require a detailed explanation, which cannot be done in a comment.